Some say tall narrow tanks are best, others say wider is better. Isn’t it personal preference, or is there actually a difference? Although personal preference certainly is important, in tanks of the same water volume, shorter wider tanks do have benefits. Here’s why.
The most important benefit of a wider tank is that it has a larger water surface area. Fish need oxygen just like we do. Oxygen exchange occurs largely where the water surface meets the air. More water surface area, equates to more oxygen exchange, an important factor for the health of your fish. A taller narrower tank may be striking in appearance, but it has less water surface area than a shorter wider tank holding the same volume of water.
Most fish require room to swim laterally (side to side), which is rather restricted in a tall narrow tank. This is especially true once plants and other decorations are added, leaving very little open space in a tall tank. Wide tanks allow for an open corridor side to side, which your fish will appreciate.
Another important factor for fish comfort is hiding places. Broader tanks offer more floor space to place rocks, driftwood, and other decorations that fish use as hiding spots. This is particularly important if you keep territorial fish, as they will claim their own space and will not allow other fish to invade their territory. In a tall thank there is little room for fish to claim their own space.
Tall hexagonal, rectangular, or round tanks can be extremely attractive, at least when they are first set up. Unfortunately the problem occurs as the tank matures and algae and mulm build up. Cleaning a tall tank is a challenge, especially if they are taller than the length of your arm. Even if your arm is long enough, unusually shaped tanks often have more corners to clean. Round or bowed tanks make the use of cleaning magnets problematical.
Decorating tall tanks is also a challenge, as decorations are generally not tall enough to fill the upper regions of the tank. The result can be less than appealing. Although tall tanks can be successfully decorated and maintained, overall the shorter wider tank offers more advantages.